Police say 40-year-old Officer Michael Paige pulled over a car in Fairmount Park on March 16th. Police say he then took one of car’s two male occupants to a secluded area of the park and had “non-consensual sexual activity” with him.

But Paige’s lawyer says the two men were allowed to drive away after being pulled over. He says the accuser dropped off his passenger and then returned to the park looking for Paige.